When a police officer’s use of force takes a life, the family left behind deserves the truth about what happened. A police brutality lawyer at Fieger Law can investigate the death, hold the officers and their agency accountable, and pursue compensation for your family under federal and Michigan law.
Fieger Law represented the family of 7-year-old Aiyana Stanley-Jones, killed during a 2010 Detroit police raid, and the family of 15-year-old Damon Grimes, who died in 2017 after a Michigan State Police trooper fired a Taser® gun at him. Both families reached multimillion-dollar settlements.
Our civil rights attorneys represent families across Michigan from our Southfield office, including in Detroit, Grand Rapids, Lansing, Flint, and Traverse City. Contact us for a free, confidential consultation. You don’t pay us anything unless we get money for you.
When a Death at the Hands of Police Becomes a Wrongful Death Claim
Police officers may use deadly force only in narrow circumstances. Under the U.S. Supreme Court’s decisions in Tennessee v. Garner and Graham v. Connor, the force an officer uses must be objectively reasonable given the threat at that moment. An officer may not use deadly force to stop a fleeing person unless there is reason to believe that person poses a significant threat of death or serious injury to others.
A police-involved death may support a wrongful death claim when it results from any of the following:
- Shootings of Unarmed or Fleeing People: An officer fires on someone who poses no immediate threat, such as a person running away or sitting in a car.
- Restraint and Chokehold Deaths: Officers kneel on, pile onto, or choke a person until the person can no longer breathe.
- Taser Deaths: An officer uses a stun device on someone who is restrained, in medical distress, or operating a moving vehicle.
- Reckless Pursuits: A high-speed chase through a neighborhood ends in a fatal crash.
- Denial of Medical Care: Officers or jail staff ignore clear signs of a medical emergency in custody.
The department will review its own officers, and that review is rarely neutral. Your family needs an independent investigation. Speak with our attorneys before you accept the department’s account of what happened.
Common Causes of Death in Police Misconduct Cases
The medical cause of death often becomes the center of the case. Autopsy findings can show whether force continued after a person stopped resisting, how long a restraint lasted, or whether a stun device triggered a cardiac event.
Common fatal injuries in these cases include gunshot wounds, positional or restraint asphyxia, strangulation from chokeholds or neck restraints, cardiac arrest after Taser use, blunt force trauma to the head, and untreated medical emergencies in jails and holding cells.
An experienced civil rights attorney can work with independent forensic pathologists to test the official findings. Call Fieger Law to begin that work while the evidence is still available.
What Your Family Should Do After a Fatal Police Shooting
The days after a police-involved death are overwhelming. A few early steps can protect your family’s ability to learn the truth:
- Request the Autopsy Report: Ask the county medical examiner for the official findings, and discuss an independent autopsy with your attorney.
- Preserve Every Recording: Save cellphone videos, doorbell or security camera footage, and social media posts that show the incident.
- Record Witness Information: Write down the names and phone numbers of anyone who saw what happened.
- Decline Recorded Statements: Do not give statements to investigators, city representatives, or insurers before you speak with a lawyer.
- Request Public Records: Body camera footage, dispatch audio, and incident reports may be available through the Michigan Freedom of Information Act.
Michigan law also requires a personal representative of the estate, appointed by the probate court, to bring the claim. Your attorney can guide your family through that step.
Internal affairs, Michigan State Police investigators, and the county prosecutor may each review the death. None of those reviews exists to protect your family’s interests. Contact our office so we can begin an independent investigation.
Civil Lawsuits vs. Criminal Charges in Police-Involved Deaths
A criminal case and a civil case are separate paths. Many families assume the first must succeed before the second can begin. The law does not work that way.
| Criminal Case | Civil Case | |
| Who Brings It | A county prosecutor, the state attorney general, or federal prosecutors | The personal representative of your loved one’s estate |
| Burden of Proof | Beyond a reasonable doubt | More likely than not |
| Main Purpose | Punishing the officer | Compensation and accountability for your family |
Criminal charges against officers remain rare. According to data from Bowling Green State University professor Philip Stinson reported by the Associated Press, 218 local officers were charged with murder or manslaughter in on-duty fatal shootings from January 2005 through July 2026. Only 78 had been convicted. Police are involved in close to 1,000 fatal encounters in the U.S. each year.
The Aiyana Stanley-Jones case shows why the civil path matters. The officer’s two criminal trials ended without a conviction. The family’s civil case still resulted in an $8.25 million settlement with the City of Detroit in 2019. Your family does not have to wait for a prosecutor to act. Call Fieger Law to discuss your options.
How Federal and Michigan Law Apply to Police Wrongful Death Claims
Most police death cases rely on federal civil rights law, Michigan law, or both.
Federal Civil Rights Claims Under Section 1983
Federal law, 42 U.S.C. § 1983, allows families to sue government officers who violate constitutional rights while acting in their official roles. Excessive force claims typically rest on the Fourth Amendment. Claims involving denial of medical care in custody may rest on the 14th Amendment.
A city or county can also be held liable when an official policy, a widespread custom, or a failure to train or supervise officers caused the death. These are known as Monell claims, after the Supreme Court’s decision in Monell v. Department of Social Services.
Section 1983 cases in Michigan are usually filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, based in Detroit, or the Western District of Michigan, based in Grand Rapids.
Michigan Wrongful Death and State Law Claims
Michigan’s Wrongful Death Act, MCL 600.2922, governs wrongful death claims in this state. Under Michigan’s governmental immunity law, MCL 691.1407, officers are generally protected from negligence claims unless their conduct amounts to gross negligence that caused the death. The statute defines gross negligence as conduct so reckless that it shows a substantial lack of concern for whether an injury results.
Claims based on intentional acts, such as assault and battery, follow separate rules. Our attorneys can evaluate which claims fit your family’s situation.
How Qualified Immunity Can Affect Your Family’s Case
Qualified immunity is a court-created doctrine that protects individual officers from Section 1983 liability unless they violated a clearly established constitutional right. In practice, courts often ask whether earlier rulings found similar conduct unconstitutional.
This defense creates real obstacles for families, including:
- Early Dismissal Motions: Officers often ask the court to dismiss the case before a jury hears the evidence.
- Appeals and Delay: Officers can often appeal a denial of qualified immunity right away, which can pause the case for months or longer.
- Limits on the Defense: Qualified immunity protects individual officers, not cities or counties. A Monell claim against a municipality is not subject to this defense.
Overcoming qualified immunity takes careful research and a detailed factual record. Our trial attorneys can begin building that record from the first day. Reach out to Fieger Law to have your family’s civil rights case reviewed.
Compensation Your Family May Be Able to Recover
Under MCL 600.2922, a court or jury may award damages that are fair and equitable under the circumstances.
Your family may be entitled to compensation for the following losses:
- Medical and Funeral Costs: Hospital, funeral, and burial expenses for which the estate is responsible
- Conscious Pain and Suffering: The pain your loved one experienced between the injury and death
- Lost Financial Support: The income and support your loved one would have provided
- Loss of Society and Companionship: The love, guidance, and companionship your family has lost
In a Section 1983 case, a jury may also award punitive damages against an individual officer whose conduct was malicious or showed reckless disregard for your loved one’s rights. Punitive damages are not available against a city or county.
There is no reliable average settlement for these cases. Value depends on the evidence, the video record, the agency’s history, and your family’s losses. The Damon Grimes family’s $12 million settlement with the Michigan State Police, approved by a federal judge in 2020, shows what is possible. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any other case. Contact our attorneys to learn which factors apply to your family’s claim.
Questions to Ask a Civil Rights Lawyer Before You Hire
Consider asking these questions during a consultation:
- Have You Handled Police-Involved Death Cases? Ask about specific cases, including federal cases.
- Who Will Handle Our Case Day to Day? Learn who will do the work and return your calls.
- What Resources Can You Commit? These cases may require forensic pathologists, use-of-force analysts, and video analysts.
- How Do You Charge for Your Services? Ask about contingency fees and case expenses.
- Are You Prepared to Try the Case? Government defendants take trial-ready lawyers more seriously.
Fieger Law has represented injured people and grieving families in Michigan courts for more than 75 years. Bring these questions to your free consultation, and expect direct answers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who Can File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit Against the Police in Michigan?
The personal representative of the deceased person’s estate files the lawsuit, often a spouse, parent, or adult child appointed by the probate court. Any recovery is distributed to eligible family members, such as a spouse, children, parents, and siblings.
Can Our Family Sue the City or Police Department, or Only the Officer?
Yes, your family may be able to sue the city or county as well as the officer. A municipality may be liable under Section 1983 when its policies, customs, or training failures caused the death.
Does the Officer Need to Be Criminally Charged Before We Can File a Civil Claim?
No. A civil case does not depend on criminal charges or a conviction, and families have recovered compensation even when no officer was convicted.
Can We Still Bring a Claim if Our Loved One Was Fleeing or Resisting?
Yes, in many situations. Police may not use deadly force against a fleeing person unless the officer has reason to believe the person poses a serious threat to others, and force must stay proportionate to any resistance. Damon Grimes did not stop for troopers, and his family still reached a $12 million settlement.
How Can We Get Body Camera Footage of Our Loved One’s Death?
Families can request body camera footage and incident reports under the Michigan Freedom of Information Act, though agencies sometimes deny requests during an open investigation. An attorney can also obtain footage through discovery once a lawsuit is filed.
What if Our Loved One Died in a Michigan Jail or Police Custody?
Your family may still have a claim. Jails must provide medical care to people in custody, and ignoring a serious medical need can violate the Constitution. These cases often turn on medical records, jail logs, and video.
How Long Does a Police Wrongful Death Lawsuit Take?
Every case moves at its own pace. Some resolve within a year or two, while cases involving qualified immunity appeals can take several years. The Aiyana Stanley-Jones case took nearly nine years, in part because of Detroit’s bankruptcy and an appeal.
How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Police Brutality Lawyer?
Fieger Law handles these cases on a contingency fee basis. You don’t pay us anything unless we get money for you. Call us today for a free consultation.
Your Family Deserves Answers After a Police-Involved Death
Fieger Law can investigate what happened, challenge the government’s version of events, and fight for the accountability your family deserves.
We represent families throughout Michigan, including Detroit, Grand Rapids, Lansing, Flint, and Traverse City. Contact Fieger Law today for a free, confidential consultation. You don’t pay us anything unless we get money for you.